top of page
BeFunky-collage.jpg

CASE STUDY 02

SAME CULTURE, DIFFERENT CONSTRAINTS: UNDERSTANDING WELLNESS JOURNEYS OF BLACK WOMEN ACROSS WEIGHT CATEGORIES

A user-centered analysis revealing how stress, environment, and social context uniquely shape the lived experiences of severely obese vs. overweight African American women in the rural South.

Overview

Background & Problem Statement

Many behavioral weight loss (BWL) programs underperform for African American women with severe obesity due to a lack of cultural relevance and their failure to address the unique psychosocial and physical challenges faced by those with severe obesity.

​

For more details, click on the button below to review the information on the Background page.

1-b.png

Research Process

Method Description

My Role

I oversaw all data analysis activities and reporting.

Business-61.png

Surveys

Baseline data from African American participants in the HHL Project were used in this analysis. Chi-Square analysis and Analysis of Variance—via multiple linear regression (MLR)—were used to assess differences between the two BMI groups (overweight & obese vs. severely obese). Participants in both studies completed a core set of demographic, health, and anthropometric measures with lifestyle study recipients receiving  additional measures addressing dietary patterns and physical activity. Objective measures were used to collect data on participants’ height, weight and steps-per-day. Data were analyzed using SAS version 9.3 (SAS Institute, Cary, NC).

Key Results

Dietary Behaviors

The mean DRA score (adjusted for age) for the severely  obese group was significantly lower than the overweight/obese group (26.2 v. 28.7, p = 0.02). Lower scores are indicative of a dietary pattern that is associated with a higher risk for CVD.   Significant differences between the two groups were found in two of four dietary sub-scores,  including lower scores for fruit and vegetable intake (8.14 vs. 7.23, p = 0.01), and drinks, desserts and snacks (8.33 vs. 7.53, p < 0.01) (all indicative of poorer dietary habits).

Physical Activity Behaviors

Significant differences between groups were found for both physical activity measures, self-report and objective (via pedometer). Using the pedometer data overweight/obese African American women averaged   approximately 5,141 steps per day compared to only 3,226 steps per day for their severely obese   counterparts (p < 0.01) a difference of about 2000 steps or the equivalent of approximately 1   mile per day of walking.

Small, but  statistically significant differences between BMI groups were found for both the PCS (43.4 vs. 40.6, p < 0.01) and MCS (50.2 vs. 49.9 p < 0.01) with severely obese women having lower (e.g. less healthy) scores. No statistically significant differences between groups were found for any of the six social support scales including the average number of close friends and relatives. Statistically significant differences between groups for the PCS and MCS variables were   found in the expected directions. The PCS and MCS consist of a series of questions that inquire   about how—if at all—the respondent’s current physical and/or emotional state has interfered   with performing activities of daily living. The PCS results support the pedometer findings from ours and other studies (described previously). In addition, qualitative studies with (racially-  heterogeneous) samples of preoperative bariatric surgery patients have found that individuals  who are severely obese report experiencing pain in their feet, knees, joints and or hips and one-  third reported back pain that can and does impair their ability to be active. 

General Physical and Mental Well-Being

Business-61.png

Surveys

Conclusion


Impact

Findings demonstrate that severely obese African American women face more significant physical, dietary, and psychosocial challenges than their overweight or moderately obese peers, underscoring the need for tailored weight loss interventions for this high-risk group. Compared to women with lower BMI, those who were severely obese were less physically active, reported poorer dietary habits, and had lower self-assessed physical and mental well-being. These disparities highlight how physical limitations and psychosocial burdens, rather than just individual motivation or knowledge, may impede healthy behavior change in this population.

 

The study’s results have important implications for public health and clinical practice. They indicate that traditional behavioral weight loss programs—often designed for general or moderately obese populations—may not sufficiently address the specific barriers faced by severely obese African American women, particularly those related to mobility challenges, mental health, stress, and social support. The findings provide empirical justification for developing more tailored, equitable interventions that incorporate strategies to reduce physical barriers, manage stress, and improve psychosocial functioning.

 

Finally, the results offer practical guidance for future intervention research by identifying the types of lifestyle, psychosocial, and environmental factors that should be considered when designing targeted programs. They also highlight the need for continued research to understand the weight loss needs of this population and evaluate the effectiveness of tailored approaches, given the high prevalence of severe obesity and disproportionate impact on African American women.

bottom of page